Onion Routing

Results of the Intermediate Node Algorithm on a Clique

The following graph is a clique. The figure below is a 6 node clique to illustrate the topology of a clique. Although not shown here, our experimentation utilized a 20 node clique.

Bridge Graph


The two following bar charts are loaded with information, so take your time reading them.

The significance of this graph is that even if a given source and destination frequently (or even always) traverse an edge (and thus two nodes), this should be considered in light of how frequently all other communicating endpoints utilize the edge. For example, suppose source X and destination Y use the edge(U,V) 100% of the time. If many other source and destination pairs use this same edge with equal (or close to) frequencies, then our concern is diminished. However, if other source and destination pairs rarely use the edge, then the fact that X and Y continuously utilize the edge might be problematic. Recall, this algorithm was executed 1000 times.

Since a 20 node clique has many edges (190), we needed to separate the following data into two bar charts.

Edge Utilization

Edge Utilization



The following tables display the results obtained from 1000 executions where A is the source with every possible destination node. Each table shows the number of times a given path was selected for a source to communicate with a destination node. It also shows the actual path taken. Note, the actual path displayed is shown in reverse order (destination to source).

This information was collected for all source-destination pairs, but we did not display all of them for obvious reasons. If there are particular source-destination pairs that you would like to see the tables, please send mail to syverson@itd.nrl.navy.mil and it will be included.

SOURCE A TO DESTINATION B:

FREQUENCY PATH
12 B K A
9 B K A O A
11 B K A O C O A
11 B K A O H O A
21 B K N R O P F Q F J A
9 B K N R O P F G M G F J A
18 B K N R O P F G T J A
12 B K N R O P F G E L E G F J A
11 B K N R O P F G E G F J A
6 B K N R O P F G F J A
10 B K N R O P F G I C I J A
9 B K N R O P F G I J A
22 B K N R O P F J A
16 B K N R O J A
36 B K N R J A
8 B K Q K A
9 B L K R H E A
11 B M B K A
5 B M Q A
11 B O A
9 B O A J A
13 B Q S P A
31 B Q G J A
14 B Q G J A P A
13 B Q G J A E A
15 B Q G J A E I O I E A
14 B Q G J A E I E A
11 B Q G J N J A
1 B R I E A
13 B S B K A
9 B S P G F T Q A
11 B S R S B K A
9 B S R E R S B K A
10 B S R F R S B K A
12 B S R F I F R S B K A
11 B T B K A
13 B T N P K A
10 B T N P L P K A
26 B T N D J B K A
13 B T J A
1 B C N G P F A
1 B C O H D H O C B A
5 B D B Q G J A
36 B D K P R A
13 B D K P R F R A
7 B D K P R G R A
12 B D K P S L S P R A
8 B D K P S L I L S P R A
11 B D K P S L I N I L S P R A
10 B D K P S M S P R A
18 B D K P S P R A
14 B D K P S C Q C S P R A
15 B D K P S C S P R A
12 B D K P H P R A
12 B D N P G F T Q A
12 B D R H Q A
10 B D E N I L S P R A
12 B E P L H Q A
13 B E P O K A
8 B E P G K A
12 B E P G K C A
21 B E P G F R H Q A
13 B E P G F R I R H Q A
14 B E P G F R J T Q A
68 B E P G F T Q A
9 B F C A
9 B F C H R K R H E A
11 B F C H R H E A
14 B F C H T M T E A
11 B F C H T E A
11 B F C H E A
1 B F D N D F T A
9 B F E A
1 B G I N P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
5 B J A
11 B J B K A
13 B J D S D J A
5 B J D J A
11 B J G A
6 B J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION C:
FREQUENCY PATH
14 C A P A
12 C A P S P A
12 C A Q A
13 C A Q T Q A
13 C A Q T J T Q A
14 C A E A
14 C A E I O I E A
13 C A E I E A
12 C A J A
10 C A J N J A
10 C A J G Q G J A
7 C A J G J A
8 C K A
13 C K N P G F T Q A
13 C K O K A
12 C K R D R H Q A
21 C K R H Q A
12 C K R I R H Q A
13 C K G P L H Q A
9 C K G P S P G F T Q A
10 C K G P E B E P G F T Q A
12 C K G P E P G F T Q A
9 C K G P G F T Q A
22 C K G F T Q A
12 C L S P R A
7 C L I L S P R A
10 C L I N E N I L S P R A
11 C L I N I L S P R A
11 C L I T J A
13 C M B K A
7 C M Q A
1 C N P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
1 C N G P F A
9 C O A
10 C O A K A
9 C O A K B K A
12 C O S B K A
11 C O H O A
1 C O H D H O C B A
14 C Q C S P R A
10 C S M S P R A
7 C S P K P R A
15 C S P K D B O A
8 C S P K D K P R A
41 C S P R A
11 C S P R A J A
11 C S P R F R A
12 C S P R G O A
8 C S P R G R A
11 C S P H P R A
1 C T F D N D F T A
13 C D N P K A
13 C D N P L P K A
9 C D N P Q K A
11 C D N T B K A
12 C D N D J B K A
23 C D J B K A
13 C F B Q G J A
5 C F B D B Q G J A
24 C F R S B K A
8 C F R E R S B K A
10 C F E A
11 C F I F R S B K A
11 C G A
9 C H R K L K R H E A
8 C H R K R H E A
12 C H R H E A
14 C H T M T E A
13 C H T E A
10 C H E A
12 C I L S D J A
14 C I L E G F J A
18 C I T J A
10 C I G M G F J A
10 C I G E G F J A
11 C I G F P O R N K B J A
8 C I G F P O R N K N R J A
13 C I G F P O R N R J A
13 C I G F P O R J A
16 C I G F P O J A
11 C I G F P F J A
22 C I G F Q F J A
14 C I G F J A
15 C I J A
5 C I J D J A
7 C I J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION D:
FREQUENCY PATH
6 D B M Q A
24 D B O A
43 D B Q G J A
14 D B Q G J A P A
13 D B Q G J A E A
13 D B Q G J A E I O I E A
12 D B Q G J A E I E A
11 D B Q G J N J A
10 D B S P G F T Q A
13 D B E P O K A
54 D B E P G F T Q A
8 D B F C A
8 D B F C H R K R H E A
11 D B F C H R H E A
13 D B F C H T M T E A
11 D B F C H T E A
10 D B F C H E A
9 D B F E A
28 D K P R A
9 D K P R A J A
12 D K P R F R A
8 D K P R G R A
13 D K P S L S P R A
8 D K P S L I L S P R A
12 D K P S L I N I L S P R A
9 D K P S M S P R A
17 D K P S P R A
14 D K P S C Q C S P R A
13 D K P S C S P R A
11 D K P H P R A
10 D L K R H E A
13 D N P K A
10 D N P L P K A
10 D N P Q K A
12 D N P Q M B K A
11 D N P G F T Q A
10 D N T B K A
11 D N T G A
1 D N D F T A
14 D N D J B K A
14 D N I F R S B K A
21 D O P F Q F J A
9 D O P F G M G F J A
16 D O P F G T J A
13 D O P F G E L E G F J A
10 D O P F G E G F J A
5 D O P F G F J A
11 D O P F G I C I J A
8 D O P F G I J A
20 D O P F J A
8 D O R N K N R J A
14 D O R N R J A
14 D O R J A
15 D O J A
9 D R K A
12 D R K C A
14 D R L H Q A
34 D R H Q A
13 D R H Q T Q A
10 D R I R H Q A
13 D R J T Q A
1 D S M F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
13 D S P A
1 D S P F A
12 D S D J A
11 D T J A
1 D C A E A
21 D C O A
11 D C O H O A
23 D C F R S B K A
8 D C F R E R S B K A
10 D E N I L S P R A
1 D H O C B A E A
5 D J A
30 D J B K A
12 D J B S B K A
11 D J B J A
7 D J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION E:
FREQUENCY PATH
1 E A B C O H D H O C B A
14 E A P A
17 E A P S P A
1 E A F A
10 E A J A
10 E A J N J A
14 E A J G Q B Q G J A
5 E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
10 E A J G Q G J A
8 E A J G J A
12 E B D R H Q A
11 E B E P G F T Q A
12 E L S D J A
12 E L E G F J A
11 E M B K A
10 E N I L S M S P R A
9 E N I L S P K P R A
71 E N I L S P R A
9 E N I L S P R A J A
11 E N I L S P R F R A
11 E N I L S P R G O A
7 E N I L S P R G R A
11 E N I L S P H P R A
14 E N I L C Q C S P R A
14 E N I L C S P R A
11 E N I T J A
14 E P L H Q A
12 E P N P G F T Q A
14 E P O K A
11 E P S P G F T Q A
9 E P G K A
11 E P G K C A
22 E P G F R H Q A
9 E P G F R I R H Q A
13 E P G F R J T Q A
56 E P G F T Q A
5 E P G F T Q M Q A
40 E R S B K A
10 E R S B K Q K A
12 E R F R S B K A
22 E R F C O A
9 E R F C O H O A
13 E R F C D N P K A
10 E R F C D N P L P K A
10 E R F C D N T B K A
13 E R F C D N D J B K A
13 E R F C D J B K A
13 E R F G A
13 E R F I F R S B K A
10 E R J B K A
11 E T M T E A
13 E T E A
13 E D B O A
8 E D K P R A
10 E F C A
1 E F D N D F T A
9 E F E A
1 E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
10 E G M G F J A
15 E G T J A
14 E G F P O R N K B J A
9 E G F P O R N K N R J A
14 E G F P O R N R J A
13 E G F P O R J A
15 E G F P O J A
12 E G F P F J A
20 E G F Q F J A
7 E G F H J A
21 E G F J A
4 E G F J D J A
13 E G I C I J A
8 E G I J A
10 E H R K L K R H E A
10 E H R K R H E A
12 E H R H E A
11 E H E A
14 E I O I E A
1 E I S K R L A
11 E I E A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION F:
FREQUENCY PATH
43 F B Q G J A
9 F B Q G J N J A
5 F B D B Q G J A
12 F P O R N K B J A
8 F P O R N K N R J A
15 F P O R N R J A
14 F P O R J A
15 F P O J A
1 F P S O H O S P F A
13 F P F J A
1 F Q D C A E A
20 F Q F J A
11 F R A
9 F R A J A
8 F R P K P R A
8 F R P K D K P R A
12 F R P R A
14 F R P S L S P R A
8 F R P S L I L S P R A
12 F R P S L I N E N I L S P R A
10 F R P S L I N I L S P R A
10 F R P S L I T J A
10 F R P S M S P R A
18 F R P S P R A
13 F R P S C Q C S P R A
15 F R P S C S P R A
10 F R P H P R A
41 F R S B K A
9 F R S B K Q K A
11 F R S B M B K A
9 F R D R H Q A
8 F R E R S B K A
11 F R G O A
13 F R G O B O A
7 F R G R A
23 F R H Q A
9 F R I R H Q A
12 F R J B K A
13 F R J T Q A
26 F T Q A
12 F T Q A C A
6 F T Q M Q A
9 F C A
22 F C O A
9 F C O H O A
11 F C D N P K A
12 F C D N P L P K A
10 F C D N T B K A
15 F C D N D J B K A
14 F C D J B K A
12 F C H R K L K R H E A
10 F C H R K R H E A
12 F C H R H E A
13 F C H T M T E A
11 F C H T E A
9 F C H E A
1 F D N D F T A
12 F E A
15 F E A P A
14 F E A P S P A
13 F E I O I E A
12 F E I E A
12 F G A
8 F G K A
10 F G M G F J A
13 F G P L H Q A
12 F G P N P G F T Q A
14 F G P O K A
12 F G P S P G F T Q A
11 F G P E B E P G F T Q A
12 F G P E P G F T Q A
10 F G P G F T Q A
14 F G T J A
13 F G E L S D J A
12 F G E L E G F J A
9 F G E G F J A
9 F G F T Q A
5 F G F J A
12 F G I C I J A
8 F G I J A
8 F H J A
1 F I Q O H D H O C B A
13 F I F R S B K A
5 F J A
1 F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
6 F J D J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION G:
FREQUENCY PATH
7 G A K A
13 G A K B K A
12 G A K B M B K A
12 G A K B S B K A
10 G A K Q K A
1 G B C O H D H O C B A
8 G K A
12 G K C A
11 G M G F J A
1 G N O C A E A
1 G N D F T A
14 G O A
13 G O B O A
14 G P L H Q A
12 G P N P G F T Q A
14 G P O K A
10 G P S P G F T Q A
10 G P E B E P G F T Q A
11 G P E P G F T Q A
1 G P F A
8 G P G F T Q A
14 G Q B Q G J A
6 G Q B D B Q G J A
11 G Q G J A
10 G R A
9 G R A J A
8 G R P K P R A
8 G R P K D K P R A
12 G R P R A
13 G R P S L S P R A
7 G R P S L I L S P R A
10 G R P S L I N E N I L S P R A
9 G R P S L I N I L S P R A
11 G R P S L I T J A
9 G R P S M S P R A
19 G R P S P R A
13 G R P S C Q C S P R A
13 G R P S C S P R A
10 G R P H P R A
11 G R F R A
9 G T B K A
10 G T N P K A
13 G T N P L P K A
26 G T N D J B K A
12 G T J A
23 G C O A
10 G C O H O A
13 G E L S D J A
12 G E L E G F J A
9 G E G F J A
12 G F P O R N K B J A
9 G F P O R N K N R J A
15 G F P O R N R J A
14 G F P O R J A
15 G F P O J A
13 G F P F J A
20 G F Q F J A
23 G F R S B K A
12 G F R D R H Q A
8 G F R E R S B K A
21 G F R H Q A
9 G F R I R H Q A
14 G F R J T Q A
38 G F T Q A
6 G F T Q M Q A
7 G F H J A
12 G F I F R S B K A
14 G F J A
4 G F J D J A
1 G I N P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
11 G I C I J A
8 G I J A
10 G J A
14 G J A P A
13 G J A P S P A
7 G J A C A
9 G J A C F E A
14 G J A E A
14 G J A E T M T E A
11 G J A E T E A
11 G J A E H R K L K R H E A
11 G J A E H R K R H E A
12 G J A E H R H E A
9 G J A E H E A
13 G J A E I O I E A
11 G J A E I E A
11 G J B K A
9 G J N J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION H:
FREQUENCY PATH
1 H K L R L J F E P N I G B A
13 H L H Q A
10 H O A
7 H O A K A
14 H O A K B K A
12 H O A K B M B K A
12 H O A K B J B K A
11 H O A K Q K A
11 H O S B K A
1 H O S P F A
11 H O C O A
10 H O C D N P K A
12 H O C D N P L P K A
9 H O C D N T B K A
12 H O C D N D J B K A
13 H O C D J B K A
22 H O C F R S B K A
9 H O C F R E R S B K A
13 H O C F I F R S B K A
11 H O C G A
10 H P K P R A
13 H P K D B O A
7 H P K D K P R A
1 H P Q D C A E A
23 H P R A
10 H P R A J A
10 H P R F R A
14 H P R G O A
7 H P R G R A
13 H P S L S P R A
7 H P S L I L S P R A
11 H P S L I N E N I L S P R A
10 H P S L I N I L S P R A
10 H P S L I T J A
12 H P S M S P R A
17 H P S P R A
14 H P S C Q C S P R A
11 H P S C S P R A
13 H Q A
13 H Q A C A
6 H Q M Q A
13 H Q T Q A
7 H R K A
12 H R K L K R H E A
14 H R K O K A
10 H R K R H E A
13 H R D N P G F T Q A
11 H R D R H Q A
10 H R F T Q A
11 H R F G P S P G F T Q A
9 H R F G P E B E P G F T Q A
11 H R F G P E P G F T Q A
10 H R F G P G F T Q A
10 H R F G F T Q A
11 H R H Q A
11 H R H E A
10 H R I R H Q A
14 H R J T Q A
13 H S D J A
13 H T M T E A
11 H T E A
7 H C A
1 H C T D L A
10 H C F E A
1 H D N D F T A
12 H E A
13 H E A P A
13 H E A P S P A
10 H E A J A
10 H E A J N J A
13 H E A J G Q B Q G J A
6 H E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
13 H E A J G Q G J A
9 H E A J G J A
14 H E I O I E A
12 H E I E A
8 H F P O R N K N R J A
15 H F P O R N R J A
13 H F P O R J A
14 H F P O J A
13 H F P F J A
21 H F Q F J A
12 H F G M G F J A
13 H F G T J A
12 H F G E L E G F J A
8 H F G E G F J A
5 H F G F J A
12 H F G I C I J A
8 H F G I J A
8 H F J A
6 H J A
13 H J B J A
5 H J D J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION I:
FREQUENCY PATH
12 I L S M S P R A
8 I L S P K P R A
13 I L S P K D B O A
7 I L S P K D K P R A
53 I L S P R A
10 I L S P R A J A
12 I L S P R F R A
10 I L S P R G O A
7 I L S P R G R A
10 I L S P H P R A
13 I L S D J A
12 I L C Q C S P R A
12 I L C S P R A
11 I L E G F J A
10 I N P K A
12 I N P L P K A
12 I N P Q K A
1 I N P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
9 I N T B K A
1 I N D F T A
35 I N D J B K A
12 I N E N I L S P R A
1 I N G P F A
11 I N I L S P R A
1 I O C T D L A
12 I O I E A
6 I R K A
13 I R K O K A
12 I R K C A
13 I R D N P G F T Q A
12 I R D R H Q A
11 I R F T Q A
11 I R F G P S P G F T Q A
10 I R F G P E B E P G F T Q A
14 I R F G P E P G F T Q A
10 I R F G P G F T Q A
9 I R F G F T Q A
32 I R H Q A
15 I R H Q T Q A
23 I T J A
13 I C I J A
14 I E A
12 I E A P A
15 I E A P S P A
10 I E A J A
10 I E A J N J A
13 I E A J G Q B Q G J A
7 I E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
12 I E A J G Q G J A
10 I E A J G J A
13 I E T M T E A
11 I E T E A
7 I E F C A
9 I E F E A
14 I E H R K L K R H E A
10 I E H R K R H E A
12 I E H R H E A
9 I E H E A
53 I F R S B K A
13 I F R S B M B K A
8 I F R E R S B K A
23 I F C O A
12 I F C O H O A
12 I F G A
11 I G M G F J A
9 I G E G F J A
13 I G F P O R N K B J A
8 I G F P O R N K N R J A
14 I G F P O R N R J A
14 I G F P O R J A
17 I G F P O J A
13 I G F P F J A
19 I G F Q F J A
13 I G F J A
7 I J A
12 I J L H Q A
7 I J M Q A
12 I J T Q A
5 I J D J A
6 I J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION J:
FREQUENCY PATH
10 J A O A
12 J A O B O A
11 J A P A
13 J A P S P A
11 J A R A
8 J A R P K P R A
8 J A R P K D K P R A
13 J A R P R A
13 J A R P S L S P R A
7 J A R P S L I L S P R A
13 J A R P S L I N E N I L S P R A
12 J A R P S L I N I L S P R A
18 J A R P S P R A
13 J A R P S C Q C S P R A
12 J A R P S C S P R A
10 J A R P H P R A
10 J A R F R A
8 J A R G R A
7 J A C A
10 J A C F E A
11 J A E A
14 J A E T M T E A
13 J A E T E A
13 J A E H R K L K R H E A
11 J A E H R K R H E A
10 J A E H R H E A
8 J A E H E A
14 J A E I O I E A
11 J A E I E A
21 J B K A
11 J B K Q K A
12 J B S B K A
13 J B J A
1 J L R L J F E P N I G B A
13 J L H Q A
13 J M B K A
1 J M N C T D L A
13 J M O K A
10 J M Q A
11 J M S P R A
10 J N J A
16 J O J A
1 J P F A
1 J Q D N D F T A
6 J R K A
8 J R N K N R J A
15 J R N R J A
10 J R S B K A
12 J R D N P G F T Q A
12 J R D R H Q A
8 J R E R S B K A
12 J R F R S B K A
9 J R F T Q A
10 J R F G P S P G F T Q A
13 J R F G P E B E P G F T Q A
12 J R F G P E P G F T Q A
10 J R F G P G F T Q A
11 J R F G F T Q A
13 J R F I F R S B K A
22 J R H Q A
14 J R J A
25 J T Q A
12 J T Q A C A
24 J T J A
12 J D N P K A
13 J D N P L P K A
9 J D N T B K A
11 J D N D J B K A
12 J D S D J A
22 J D C O A
11 J D C O H O A
7 J D J A
10 J D J B K A
1 J E A
13 J F P F J A
18 J F Q F J A
11 J F G M G F J A
11 J F G E L E G F J A
8 J F G E G F J A
7 J F G F J A
7 J F J A
11 J G A
11 J G Q B Q G J A
8 J G Q B D B Q G J A
14 J G Q G J A
10 J G J A
5 J H J A
9 J I R H Q A
12 J I C I J A
8 J I J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION K:
FREQUENCY PATH
1 K A L D T C T D L A
12 K A O A
11 K A O C O A
9 K A O H O A
12 K A Q A
13 K A Q T Q A
11 K A G A
13 K B K A
12 K B M B K A
13 K B S B K A
10 K B S R S B K A
7 K B S R E R S B K A
11 K B S R F R S B K A
12 K B S R F I F R S B K A
12 K B J A
13 K B J B K A
13 K L K R H E A
1 K L R L J F E P N I G B A
8 K M Q A
12 K N P G F T Q A
19 K N R O P F Q F J A
12 K N R O P F G M G F J A
13 K N R O P F G T J A
12 K N R O P F G E L E G F J A
8 K N R O P F G E G F J A
6 K N R O P F G F J A
12 K N R O P F G I C I J A
7 K N R O P F G I J A
21 K N R O P F J A
16 K N R O J A
37 K N R J A
5 K N R J D J A
5 K N R J H J A
14 K O K A
1 K O S P F A
11 K P K A
13 K P L P K A
8 K P N T B K A
22 K P N D J B K A
24 K P R A
9 K P R A J A
11 K P R F R A
9 K P R G O A
8 K P R G R A
14 K P S L S P R A
7 K P S L I L S P R A
12 K P S L I N E N I L S P R A
11 K P S L I N I L S P R A
9 K P S L I T J A
13 K P S M S P R A
16 K P S P R A
14 K P S C Q C S P R A
11 K P S C S P R A
10 K P H P R A
11 K Q K A
10 K R D R H Q A
20 K R H Q A
14 K R H T M T E A
11 K R H T E A
8 K R H C A
10 K R H C F E A
31 K R H E A
11 K R H E A P A
13 K R H E A P S P A
12 K R H E A J A
10 K R H E A J N J A
11 K R H E A J G Q B Q G J A
7 K R H E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
12 K R H E A J G Q G J A
10 K R H E A J G J A
14 K R H E I O I E A
12 K R H E I E A
8 K R I R H Q A
1 K R I E A
13 K R J T Q A
14 K S D J A
12 K C A
13 K D B O A
8 K D K P R A
1 K E F D N D F T A
13 K G P L H Q A
11 K G P S P G F T Q A
11 K G P E B E P G F T Q A
13 K G P E P G F T Q A
10 K G P G F T Q A
19 K G F T Q A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION L:
FREQUENCY PATH
48 L B Q G J A
10 L B Q G J N J A
13 L K R H T M T E A
10 L K R H T E A
7 L K R H C A
10 L K R H C F E A
41 L K R H E A
11 L K R H E A P A
14 L K R H E A P S P A
15 L K R H E I O I E A
12 L K R H E I E A
18 L P K A
12 L P K B K A
12 L P K B S B K A
12 L P N P G F T Q A
8 L P N T B K A
13 L P N T G A
24 L P N D C O A
10 L P N D C O H O A
19 L P N D C F R S B K A
8 L P N D C F R E R S B K A
36 L P N D J B K A
13 L P N I F R S B K A
15 L P O K A
13 L P Q K A
13 L P Q M B K A
11 L P S P G F T Q A
11 L P E B E P G F T Q A
13 L P E P G F T Q A
7 L P G K A
29 L P G F T Q A
1 L Q D N D F T A
1 L R L J F E P N I G B A
11 L R D R H Q A
10 L R H Q A
11 L S M S P R A
10 L S P K P R A
13 L S P K D B O A
9 L S P K D K P R A
40 L S P R A
9 L S P R A J A
12 L S P R F R A
11 L S P R G O A
8 L S P R G R A
10 L S P H P R A
12 L S D J A
11 L C Q C S P R A
11 L C S P R A
8 L D B Q G J A
1 L D T C T D L A
1 L E A
12 L E G M G F J A
11 L E G T J A
12 L E G F P O R N K B J A
9 L E G F P O R N K N R J A
15 L E G F P O R N R J A
14 L E G F P O R J A
17 L E G F P O J A
14 L E G F P F J A
18 L E G F Q F J A
6 L E G F H J A
33 L E G F J A
5 L E G F J D J A
1 L F D F L S A
26 L H Q A
12 L H Q A C A
8 L H Q M Q A
13 L H Q T Q A
10 L I L S P R A
12 L I N E N I L S P R A
11 L I N I L S P R A
11 L I T J A
12 L I C I J A
9 L I J A
13 L J T Q A
8 L J I R H Q A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION M:
FREQUENCY PATH
21 M B K A
13 M B S B K A
11 M B D R H Q A
10 M B E P G F T Q A
6 M K A
1 M L F D F L S A
1 M N C T D L A
14 M O K A
13 M Q A
12 M Q K A
11 M Q P K A
14 M Q P L P K A
8 M Q P N T B K A
23 M Q P N D J B K A
12 M Q T Q A
8 M Q T F T Q A
11 M Q T F G P N P G F T Q A
13 M Q T F G P S P G F T Q A
12 M Q T F G P E P G F T Q A
8 M Q T F G P G F T Q A
11 M Q T F G F T Q A
13 M Q H Q A
10 M Q H R H Q A
15 M S L S P R A
8 M S L I L S P R A
12 M S L I N E N I L S P R A
10 M S L I N I L S P R A
11 M S L I T J A
7 M S P K P R A
12 M S P K D B O A
8 M S P K D K P R A
40 M S P R A
12 M S P R F R A
12 M S P R G O A
11 M S P R G R A
9 M S P H P R A
11 M S C Q C S P R A
12 M S C S P R A
23 M T E A
11 M T E A P A
12 M T E A P S P A
11 M T E A J A
12 M T E A J N J A
11 M T E A J G Q B Q G J A
8 M T E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
14 M T E A J G Q G J A
10 M T E A J G J A
13 M T E I O I E A
13 M T E I E A
12 M T H R K L K R H E A
8 M T H R K R H E A
14 M T H R H E A
9 M T H C A
11 M T H C F E A
7 M T H E A
12 M C A
1 M C A P G L K L G P A
24 M C O A
8 M C O H O A
1 M E A
19 M E R S B K A
10 M E R F R S B K A
12 M E R F I F R S B K A
1 M F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
11 M G T J A
12 M G E L S D J A
13 M G E L E G F J A
8 M G E G F J A
12 M G F P O R N K B J A
9 M G F P O R N K N R J A
15 M G F P O R N R J A
14 M G F P O R J A
16 M G F P O J A
13 M G F P F J A
18 M G F Q F J A
8 M G F H J A
23 M G F J A
5 M G F J D J A
12 M G I C I J A
10 M G I J A
9 M J A
13 M J B K A
14 M J L H Q A
14 M J T Q A
11 M J G A
7 M J I R H Q A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION N:
FREQUENCY PATH
7 N K A
12 N K B J A
9 N K N R J A
15 N K S D J A
12 N K C A
1 N O C A E A
11 N P K A
13 N P L P K A
15 N P L H Q A
16 N P O K A
12 N P Q K A
13 N P Q M B K A
12 N P S P G F T Q A
11 N P E B E P G F T Q A
10 N P E P G F T Q A
1 N P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
25 N P G F R H Q A
8 N P G F R I R H Q A
13 N P G F R J T Q A
52 N P G F T Q A
8 N P G F T Q M Q A
19 N R O P F Q F J A
12 N R O P F G M G F J A
12 N R O P F G T J A
13 N R O P F G E L E G F J A
7 N R O P F G E G F J A
6 N R O P F G F J A
11 N R O P F G I C I J A
9 N R O P F G I J A
22 N R O P F J A
17 N R O J A
23 N R J A
5 N R J D J A
7 N R J H J A
9 N T B K A
13 N T G A
1 N C T D L A
1 N D A P G L K L G P A
10 N D R H Q A
23 N D C O A
7 N D C O H O A
19 N D C F R S B K A
10 N D C F R E R S B K A
44 N D J B K A
13 N D J B S B K A
11 N E N I L S P R A
11 N I L S M S P R A
7 N I L S P K P R A
11 N I L S P K D B O A
9 N I L S P K D K P R A
63 N I L S P R A
9 N I L S P R A J A
11 N I L S P R F R A
12 N I L S P R G O A
10 N I L S P R G R A
9 N I L S P H P R A
11 N I L C Q C S P R A
12 N I L C S P R A
13 N I T J A
12 N I F R S B K A
11 N J A
13 N J A P A
13 N J A P S P A
6 N J A C A
11 N J A C F E A
10 N J A E A
12 N J A E T M T E A
10 N J A E T E A
12 N J A E H R K L K R H E A
10 N J A E H R K R H E A
13 N J A E H R H E A
8 N J A E H E A
16 N J A E I O I E A
13 N J A E I E A
1 N J D F L S A
10 N J G Q B Q G J A
9 N J G Q B D B Q G J A
12 N J G Q G J A
10 N J G J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION O:
FREQUENCY PATH
5 O A K A
12 O A K B K A
14 O A K B M B K A
15 O A K B J B K A
12 O A K Q K A
10 O A J A
11 O A J T J A
12 O B O A
8 O B D K P R A
7 O K A
13 O K A Q A
15 O K A Q T Q A
11 O K R D R H Q A
26 O K R H Q A
8 O K R I R H Q A
16 O K R J T Q A
12 O K C A
9 O M Q A
12 O P L H Q A
12 O P N P G F T Q A
12 O P S P G F T Q A
1 O P C D F L S A
10 O P E B E P G F T Q A
10 O P E P G F T Q A
19 O P F Q F J A
13 O P F G M G F J A
12 O P F G T J A
13 O P F G E L S D J A
14 O P F G E L E G F J A
7 O P F G E G F J A
6 O P F G F J A
11 O P F G I C I J A
10 O P F G I J A
25 O P F J A
26 O P G F T Q A
10 O R N K B J A
9 O R N K N R J A
17 O R N R J A
14 O R J A
12 O S B K A
1 O C A E A
11 O C O A
1 O C T D L A
9 O C D N P K A
14 O C D N P L P K A
9 O C D N T B K A
11 O C D N D J B K A
13 O C D J B K A
17 O C F R S B K A
10 O C F R E R S B K A
13 O C F I F R S B K A
14 O C G A
5 O D J A
1 O F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
1 O G L K L G P A
21 O G R A
7 O G R P K P R A
12 O G R P R A
16 O G R P S L S P R A
11 O G R P S L I L S P R A
11 O G R P S L I N E N I L S P R A
10 O G R P S L I N I L S P R A
11 O G R P S M S P R A
16 O G R P S P R A
11 O G R P S C Q C S P R A
12 O G R P S C S P R A
8 O G R P H P R A
12 O G R F R A
8 O H O A
23 O I E A
12 O I E A P A
12 O I E A P S P A
13 O I E A J A
12 O I E A J N J A
11 O I E A J G Q B Q G J A
10 O I E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
14 O I E A J G Q G J A
9 O I E A J G J A
16 O I E T M T E A
9 O I E T E A
6 O I E F C A
10 O I E F E A
12 O I E H R K L K R H E A
10 O I E H R K R H E A
11 O I E H R H E A
9 O I E H E A
9 O J A
5 O J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION P:
FREQUENCY PATH
1 P A L D T C T D L A
6 P A C A
11 P A C F E A
9 P A E A
14 P A E T M T E A
9 P A E T E A
12 P A E H R K L K R H E A
9 P A E H R K R H E A
11 P A E H R H E A
8 P A E H E A
15 P A E I O I E A
15 P A E I E A
11 P A J A
11 P A J N J A
10 P A J G Q B Q G J A
12 P A J G Q B D B Q G J A
13 P A J G Q G J A
11 P A J G J A
7 P K A
12 P K B K A
12 P K B S B K A
6 P K P R A
11 P K D B O A
10 P K D K P R A
14 P L P K A
10 P L H Q A
12 P N P G F T Q A
9 P N T B K A
14 P N T G A
21 P N D C O A
9 P N D C O H O A
17 P N D C F R S B K A
11 P N D C F R E R S B K A
37 P N D J B K A
12 P N I F R S B K A
15 P O K A
10 P O R N K B J A
9 P O R N K N R J A
17 P O R N R J A
14 P O R J A
15 P O J A
11 P Q K A
13 P Q M B K A
1 P Q D C A E A
11 P R A
11 P R A J A
11 P R F R A
11 P R G O A
10 P R G R A
15 P S L S P R A
11 P S L I L S P R A
11 P S L I N E N I L S P R A
12 P S L I N I L S P R A
11 P S L I T J A
10 P S M S P R A
12 P S P A
17 P S P R A
11 P S P G F T Q A
10 P S C Q C S P R A
13 P S C S P R A
1 P C D F L S A
10 P E B D R H Q A
13 P E B E P G F T Q A
10 P E P G F T Q A
1 P E F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
18 P F Q F J A
13 P F G M G F J A
12 P F G T J A
12 P F G E L S D J A
15 P F G E L E G F J A
7 P F G E G F J A
8 P F G F J A
11 P F G I C I J A
11 P F G I J A
6 P F H J A
16 P F J A
5 P F J D J A
8 P G K A
13 P G K C A
1 P G L K L G P A
24 P G F R H Q A
7 P G F R I R H Q A
13 P G F R J T Q A
44 P G F T Q A
9 P G F T Q M Q A
8 P H P R A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION Q:
FREQUENCY PATH
7 Q A K A
15 Q A K O K A
1 Q A L D T C T D L A
16 Q A C A
13 Q B L K R H E A
11 Q B Q G J A
12 Q B D B Q G J A
7 Q B F C A
10 Q B F E A
7 Q K A
12 Q K B K A
13 Q K B S B K A
10 Q K B S R S B K A
10 Q K B S R E R S B K A
8 Q K B S R F R S B K A
13 Q K B J B K A
1 Q K N B E A
13 Q M B K A
8 Q M Q A
10 Q P K A
14 Q P L P K A
9 Q P N T B K A
14 Q P N T G A
20 Q P N D C O A
10 Q P N D C O H O A
23 Q P N D J B K A
13 Q P N I F R S B K A
12 Q S P A
12 Q T Q A
9 Q T F T Q A
10 Q T F G P N P G F T Q A
11 Q T F G P S P G F T Q A
12 Q T F G P E B E P G F T Q A
12 Q T F G P E P G F T Q A
10 Q T F G P G F T Q A
9 Q T F G F T Q A
15 Q T J T Q A
1 Q C A P G L K L G P A
15 Q C L S P R A
10 Q C L I L S P R A
13 Q C L I N E N I L S P R A
12 Q C L I N I L S P R A
12 Q C L I T J A
11 Q C S M S P R A
7 Q C S P K P R A
11 Q C S P K D B O A
9 Q C S P K D K P R A
50 Q C S P R A
9 Q C S P R A J A
11 Q C S P R F R A
12 Q C S P R G O A
8 Q C S P R G R A
9 Q C S P H P R A
9 Q F P O R N K B J A
10 Q F P O R N K N R J A
15 Q F P O R N R J A
14 Q F P O R J A
16 Q F P O J A
13 Q F P F J A
1 Q F D F L S A
13 Q F G M G F J A
13 Q F G T J A
11 Q F G E L S D J A
15 Q F G E L E G F J A
10 Q F G E G F J A
7 Q F G F J A
13 Q F G I C I J A
10 Q F G I J A
6 Q F H J A
17 Q F J A
1 Q F J L R L J F E P N I G B A
7 Q F J D J A
21 Q G J A
12 Q G J A P A
10 Q G J A E A
14 Q G J A E T M T E A
10 Q G J A E T E A
9 Q G J A E H R K R H E A
12 Q G J A E H R H E A
8 Q G J A E H E A
14 Q G J A E I O I E A
13 Q G J A E I E A
11 Q G J N J A
10 Q H L H Q A
12 Q H Q A
11 Q H R D R H Q A
13 Q H R H Q A
7 Q H R I R H Q A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION R:
FREQUENCY PATH
10 R A J A
7 R K A
12 R K L K R H E A
14 R K O K A
10 R K R H E A
14 R K C A
1 R L D T C T D L A
11 R L H Q A
1 R L J F Q E P N I G B A
10 R N K B J A
10 R N K N R J A
12 R N K S D J A
15 R N R J A
18 R O P F Q F J A
14 R O P F G M G F J A
12 R O P F G T J A
14 R O P F G E L E G F J A
8 R O P F G E G F J A
8 R O P F G F J A
10 R O P F G I C I J A
9 R O P F G I J A
24 R O P F J A
16 R O J A
6 R P K P R A
10 R P K D K P R A
12 R P R A
14 R P S L S P R A
10 R P S L I L S P R A
10 R P S L I N E N I L S P R A
11 R P S L I N I L S P R A
11 R P S L I T J A
11 R P S M S P R A
17 R P S P R A
13 R P S C Q C S P R A
13 R P S C S P R A
10 R P H P R A
30 R S B K A
10 R S B K Q K A
13 R S B M B K A
11 R D N P G F T Q A
10 R D R H Q A
1 R D F L S A
11 R E R S B K A
1 R F K L G P A
10 R F R A
7 R F R S B K A
10 R F T Q A
23 R F C O A
9 R F C O H O A
12 R F C D N P K A
13 R F C D N P L P K A
9 R F C D N T B K A
11 R F C D N D J B K A
12 R F C D J B K A
14 R F G A
12 R F G P S P G F T Q A
12 R F G P E B E P G F T Q A
13 R F G P E P G F T Q A
10 R F G P G F T Q A
9 R F G F T Q A
12 R F I F R S B K A
11 R G O A
12 R G O B O A
8 R G R A
1 R G D B N K N B E A
24 R H Q A
8 R H Q M Q A
12 R H Q T Q A
13 R H T M T E A
11 R H T E A
9 R H C A
10 R H C F E A
17 R H E A
13 R H E A P A
13 R H E A P S P A
10 R H E A J A
12 R H E A J N J A
9 R H E A J G Q B Q G J A
11 R H E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
12 R H E A J G Q G J A
9 R H E A J G J A
15 R H E I O I E A
13 R H E I E A
7 R I R H Q A
9 R J A
13 R J B K A
15 R J T Q A
5 R J D J A
5 R J H J A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION S:
FREQUENCY PATH
19 S B K A
11 S B K Q K A
14 S B M B K A
10 S B D R H Q A
12 S B E P G F T Q A
14 S B J B K A
16 S B J G A
38 S K N R J A
1 S L K L G P A
14 S L S P R A
12 S L E G M G F J A
10 S L E G T J A
16 S L E G F P O J A
13 S L E G F P F J A
16 S L E G F Q F J A
39 S L E G F J A
1 S L F D F L S A
13 S L I L S P R A
11 S L I N E N I L S P R A
12 S L I N I L S P R A
11 S L I T J A
11 S L I C I J A
8 S L I J A
11 S M S P R A
1 S N C T D L A
10 S O A
12 S O C O A
11 S O C D N P K A
13 S O C D N P L P K A
9 S O C D N T B K A
10 S O C D N D J B K A
12 S O C D J B K A
10 S O H O A
13 S P A
8 S P A C A
10 S P A C F E A
8 S P A E A
13 S P A E T M T E A
11 S P A E T E A
13 S P A E H R K L K R H E A
11 S P A E H R K R H E A
12 S P A E H R H E A
9 S P A E H E A
16 S P A E I O I E A
13 S P A E I E A
6 S P K P R A
12 S P K D B O A
11 S P K D K P R A
9 S P L H Q A
12 S P N P G F T Q A
14 S P O K A
24 S P R A
10 S P R A J A
9 S P R F R A
13 S P R G O A
8 S P R G R A
12 S P E P G F T Q A
9 S P G K A
15 S P G K C A
22 S P G F R H Q A
8 S P G F R I R H Q A
14 S P G F R J T Q A
53 S P G F T Q A
9 S P G F T Q M Q A
9 S P H P R A
10 S Q B Q G J A
31 S Q G J A
11 S Q G J N J A
8 S R S B K A
11 S R E R S B K A
7 S R F R S B K A
12 S R F I F R S B K A
14 S C Q C S P R A
11 S C S P R A
1 S C F P O K N B E A
10 S D B Q G J A
16 S D J A
10 S D J B J A
10 S H J A
1 S J C P A


SOURCE A TO DESTINATION T:
FREQUENCY PATH
18 T B K A
9 T B O A
12 T B S B K A
12 T M T E A
1 T N K N B E A
10 T N P K A
14 T N P L P K A
10 T N P Q K A
13 T N P Q M B K A
21 T N D C O A
9 T N D C O H O A
15 T N D C F R S B K A
11 T N D C F R E R S B K A
38 T N D J B K A
13 T N I F R S B K A
10 T Q A
8 T Q A K A
15 T Q A C A
8 T Q M Q A
10 T Q H Q A
9 T Q H R D R H Q A
12 T Q H R H Q A
8 T Q H R I R H Q A
1 T C T D L A
1 T D A P G L K L G P A
9 T D K P R A
8 T E A
13 T E A P A
11 T E A P S P A
10 T E A J A
11 T E A J N J A
11 T E A J G Q B Q G J A
10 T E A J G Q B D B Q G J A
12 T E A J G Q G J A
8 T E A J G J A
1 T E B K C P A
14 T E I O I E A
15 T E I E A
10 T F T Q A
1 T F D F L S A
10 T F G P L H Q A
12 T F G P N P G F T Q A
14 T F G P O K A
13 T F G P S P G F T Q A
13 T F G P E B E P G F T Q A
12 T F G P E P G F T Q A
12 T F G P G F T Q A
10 T F G F T Q A
15 T G A
12 T G M G F J A
13 T G E L S D J A
14 T G E L E G F J A
7 T G E G F J A
9 T G F P O R N K B J A
13 T G F P O R N K N R J A
18 T G F P O R N R J A
12 T G F P O R J A
16 T G F P O J A
12 T G F P F J A
16 T G F Q F J A
18 T G F J A
13 T H R K L K R H E A
11 T H R K R H E A
11 T H R H E A
10 T H C A
10 T H C F E A
9 T H E A
12 T I L S M S P R A
7 T I L S P K P R A
66 T I L S P R A
9 T I L S P R F R A
12 T I L S P R G O A
8 T I L S P R G R A
9 T I L S P H P R A
14 T I L C Q C S P R A
11 T I L C S P R A
11 T I N E N I L S P R A
12 T I N I L S P R A
10 T I C I J A
7 T I J A
19 T J A
13 T J T Q A
6 T J D J A
7 T J H J A






Historical page reflecting onion-router.net as of 2005, not regularly maintained. Address questions to Paul Syverson.